The sudden fall of Paula Deen is, if anything, breath-taking. And to fall because of a an ancient racial slur — surely injustice is at work? Bill Vis comments
Paula Deen is older than me and was born and raised in the south. The furor by younger people shows a profound lack of understanding of the world she and I grew up in. Was it right? Something I am proud of? Of course not! But to condemn someone in her mid-sixties for being a product of the society in which she was a child is grossly unfair.
Was it unfair what happened to Paula Deen? In a sense, absolutely, the same way it was unfair what happened to Detroit autoworkers. She got caught in an ebbing tide.
Her problem is not that she was brought up a certain way, but that she could not adapt to the present rapidly changing make-up of US society. David Brooks’ column , A Nation of Mutts captures much of the new dynamic, about the shift from Euro-America to a New America. In this landscape, the older folkways are now peculiar, particular to the individual. And perhaps especially those of the South,with its own complicated history on race. To participate in cultural leadership or take a culturally visible role such as Deen had done requires that one be able to present oneself as culturally open. Her inarticulateness — her real sin — then doomed her.
But it may not have been just a few ill-chosen words.
Adding to the conflagration may be our own politics. The national political scene is dominated not only by an open hostility to a representative of this new America, President Obama, but also by a retrenchment of conservative ideals. There’s a dynamic there between the political and cultural concerns of the conservative base so firmly anchored in the white Baby Boom generation and the New American mixed identity of the President. In this mix, Deen’s comments however old, even her southern identity give her the appearance of some one on that conservative side. There’s already enough heat in the politics, her misstep provided the oxygen that consumed her.